1993 NCAA Division III
Seed No. 4 Regional (3-2) |
| William Paterson |
W |
6-5 |
| Rowan |
L |
2-3 |
| William Paterson |
W |
7-4 |
| Rowan |
W |
4-3 |
| Rowan |
L |
1-9 |
1994 NCAA Division III
Seed No. 2 Regional (1-2) |
| William Paterson |
W |
8-6 |
| Rowan |
L |
3-9 |
| Buffalo State |
L |
4-5 |
1995 NCAA Division III
Seed No. 2 Regional (2-2) |
| Christopher Newport |
W |
9-1 |
| The College of New Jersey |
W |
5-4 |
| The College of New Jersey |
L |
3-5 |
| The College of New Jersey |
L |
1-2 |
1996 NCAA Division III
Seed No. 2 Regional (2-2) |
| Rowan |
L |
2-4 |
| Messiah |
W |
13-4 |
| Rowan |
W |
6-0 |
| The College of New Jersey |
L |
2-3 |
1997 NCAA Division III
Seed No. 1 Regional (4-1) |
| Bethany (WVa) |
W |
2-1 |
| Salisbury |
L |
9-10 |
| Rowan |
W |
3-2 |
| Salisbury |
W |
8-0 |
| Salisbury |
W |
5-2 |
1997 NCAA Division III
Softball Championship (2-2) |
| Wheaton (MA) |
W |
6-1 |
| Simpson (IA) |
L |
0-6 |
| Wheaton (MA) |
W |
3-2 |
| Simpson (IA) |
L |
1-2 |
1998 NCAA Division III
Atlantic Regional (0-1) |
| William Paterson |
L |
1-6 |
1999 NCAA Division III
Atlantic Regional (2-2) |
| The College of New Jersey |
L |
2-4 |
| Roanoke (VA) |
W |
7-3 |
| Salisbury |
W |
3-2 |
| The College of New Jersey |
L |
2-5 |
2007 NCAA Division III
Montclair, NJ Regional (3-2) |
| Manhattanville |
W |
3-2 (9) |
| Staten Island |
W |
3-1 |
| Moravian |
L |
9-2 |
| Ramapo |
W |
2-0 |
| Moravian |
L |
8-2 |
2008 NCAA Division III
Plattsburgh Regional (1-2) |
| Cortland |
L |
2-0 |
| Springfield |
W |
6-0 |
| Eastern Connecticut |
L |
3-2 |
