| 1988 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament |
|
| Drew University 14, Montclair State 2 (@ Madison, NJ - Championship) |
| 1989 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament |
|
| Montclair State 10, Kean College 3 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Championship) |
| 1990 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament |
|
| Kean College 15, Montclair State 11 (@ Union, NJ - Championship) |
| 1991 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament |
|
Montclair State 14, Queens College 8 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - First Round)
Kean College 15, Montclair State 8 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Championship) |
| 1992 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament |
|
Montclair State 12, Kean College 10 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - First Round)
Montclair State 17, Manhattanville 8 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Championship)
Most Valuable Player - Ken Kane, Goalkeeper |
| 1994 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament |
 |
Montclair State 18, Upsala 11 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - First Round)
Montclair State 18, Drew University 12 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Championship) |
| 2003 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament |
|
Montclair State 13, Centenary 6 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - First Round)
Montclair State 10, Kings Point 9 (OT) (@ Kings Point, NY - Championship)
Most Valuable Player - Chris Meixner, Midfield |
| 2004 Skyline Conference Tournament |
|
Montclair State 14, Richard Stockton 9 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Semifinals)
Stevens 23, Montclair State 9 (@Hoboken, NJ - Championship) |
| 2004 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament |
|
Montclair State 13, Farmingdale 5 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - First Round)
Montclair State 13, Richard Stockton 3 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Championship)
Most Valuable Player - Alan Annazone, Goalkeeper |
| 2005 Skyline Conference Tournament |
|
Montclair State 13, Kings Point 11 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Semifinals)
Stevens 21, Montclair State 8 (@Hoboken, NJ - Championship) |
| 2005 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament |
|
Montclair State 13, Farmingdale 8 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - First Round)
Most Valuable Player - Kevin Gondres, Attack |
| 2006 Knickerbocker Conference Tournament |
|
| Stevens 21, Montclair State 8 (@Hoboken, NJ - First Round) |
| 2006 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament |
|
Montclair State 12, Richard Stockton 11 (@ Pomona, NJ - First Round)
Villa Julie 15, Montclair State 8 (@ Owings Mills, MD - Championship) |
| 2007 Skyline Conference Tournament |
|
| Kings Point 8, Montclair State 5 (@ Kings Point, NY - Semifinals) |
| 2007 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament |
|
Montclair State 17, Drew 13 (@ Montclair, NJ - Semifinals)
Stevens 17, Montclair State 6 (@ Hoboken, NJ - Championship) |
| 2008 Skyline Conference Tournament |
|
Montclair State 13, Richard Stockton 3 (@ Montclair, NJ- Semifinals)
Kean 8, Montclair State 7 (@ Montclair, NJ - Championship) |
