| 1968 NCAA College Division East Regional |
 |
Montclair State 2, Univ. of Baltimore 0 (@ Springfield, MA)
Springfield 6, Montclair State 0 (@ Springfield, MA) |
| 1969 NCAA College Division Tournament |
|
Montclair State 4, Long Island University 2 (@ Brooklyn, NY)
Univ of Pennsylvania 3, Montclair State 0 (@ Phildelphia, PA) |
| 1972 NCAA College Division Tournament |
|
| E. Stroudsburg 2, Montclair State 1 (@ E. Stroudsburg, PA) |
|
| 1988 ECAC Division III Tournament |
 |
Montclair State 1, Drew 0 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Metro Opening Round)
Montclair State 2, NJIT 0 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Metro Championship)
Williams 1, Montclair State 0 (@ Williamstown, MA - ECAC Semifinals) |
| 1989 NCAA Division III Tournament |
|
Montclair State 2, Muhlenberg 0 (@ Center Valley, PA)
Elizabethtown 1, Montclair State 0 (@ Elizabethtown, PA) |
| 1990 NCAA Division III Tournament |
|
| Glassboro State 4, Montclair State 1 (@ Glassboro, NJ) |
| 1991 NCAA Division III Tournament |
|
| Trenton State 1, Montclair State 0 (@ Ewing Township, NJ) |
| 1992 NCAA Division III Tournament |
|
| Kean 3, Montclair State 2 (@ Glassboro, NJ) |
| 1993 ECAC Division III Tournament |
|
Montclair State 2, Kings Point 1 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ)
Montclair State 3, Drew University 0 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ) |
| 1994 ECAC Division III Tournament |
|
Montclair State 1, Stony Brook 0 (at Stony Brook, NY)
Vassar 1, Montclair State 0 (at Poughkeepsie, NY) |
| 1995 ECAC Division III Tournament |
|
Montclair State 3, Drew 2 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Semifinals)
Kean 3, Montclair State 0 (@ Union, NJ - Championship) |
| 1996 NCAA Division III Tournament |
|
| Richard Stockton 3, Montclair State 1 (@ Pomona, NJ) |
| 1997 ECAC Division III Tournament |
|
Montclair State 2, Richard Stockton 1 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Semifinals)
Drew 1, Montclair State 0 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Championship) |
| 1998 NCAA Division III Tournament |
|
| Rowan 1, Montclair State 0 (@ Glassboro, NJ) |
| 2000 ECAC Division III Tournament |
|
Montclair State 1, St. Joseph's (NY) 0 (@ Patchogue, NY - 1st Round)
Montclair State 1, New Jersey City 0 (@ Jersey City, NJ - Semifinals)
Ri. Stockton 1, Montclair State 0 (2OT) (@ Pomona, NJ - Championship) |
| 2002 ECAC Division III Tournament |
|
Montclair State 1, Ramapo 0 (@ Mahwah, NJ - 1st Round)
Montclair State 2, NYU 1 (@ New York, NY - Semifinals)
Stevens 1, Montclair State 0 (2OT) (@ Hoboken, NJ - Championship) |
| 2003 ECAC Division III Tournament |
|
Montclair State 3, Manhattanville 3 (4-2 PK) (@ Montclair, NJ - 1st Rd)
Montclair State 3, New Jersey City 2 (@ Montclair, NJ - Semifinals)
Montclair State 1, Ramapo 0 (@ Montclair, NJ - Championship Game) |
| 2006 NCAA Division III Tournament |
|
Montclair State 1, Wesleyan (CT) 0 (Second Round - @ Montclair, NJ)
Montclair State 1, Dominican (IL) 1 (Dominican 4-2 PK) (Sectionals - @ Cleveland, OH) |
| 2007 NCAA Division III Tournament |
 |
Montclair State 2, Penn State Behrend 1 (Second Round - @ Montclair, NJ)
Montclair State , New Jersey City 2 (OT) (Sectionals Semifinal - @ Grantham, PA)
Messiah College 1, Montclair State 0 (Sectional Final - @ Grantham, PA) |
