1999 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament
Richard Stockton 1, Montclair State 0 (@ Poughkeepsie, NY)
2000 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament
Montclair State 7, Ramapo 1 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - 1st Round) Montclair State 1, Wm. Paterson 0 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Semifinals) Montclair State 1, New York Univ. 0 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Semifinals)
2001 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament
Montclair State 1, Richard Stockton 0 (at Upper Montclair, NJ - Semifinals) New York Univ. 2, Montclair State 0 (at New York, NY - Championship)
2002 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament
Montclair State 3, Manhattanville 0 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Semifinals) R. Stockton 2, Montclair State 1 (OT) (@ Upp. Montclair, NJ - Championship)
2003 ECAC Division III Metro Tournament
Montclair State 1, Centenary 0 (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Semifinals) R. Stockton 1, MSU 1 (RSC 4-2 PK) (@ Upper Montclair, NJ - Championship)
2004 NCAA Division III Tournament
Montclair State 4, Bay Path (MA) 0 (@ Montclair, NJ - 1st Round) Messiah 0, MSU 0 (Messiah 3-2 PK) (@ Montclair, NJ - 2nd Round)
2006 NCAA Division III Tournament
Montclair State 1, Nazareth 0 (@ Elizabethtown, PA - 1st Round) Elizabethtown 1, Montclair State 0 (OT) (@ Elizabethtown, PA - 2nd Round)